Comments
DukeJules
A unique film with a style all its own. I loved the dark portrayal of the city and its inhabitants. The story of Marv is the best of the three with its exciting fighting scenes and character development.
jeremydw
Absolutely the best graphic novel to film conversion I've ever seen. It's so true to the novel it's almost unbelievable. The extended versions are even more like the novel and broken up like the novels. The theatrical cut is pretty good but is more like a non-linear loosely connected movie. It's hard to consider style and substance because the art and stories are taken verbatim from the novel to film.
Dieguito
Excellent scenes and crazy characters.
In 10 official lists
AT #83
AT #171
AT #368